Watch: Shubman Gill clashes with umpires after Glenn Phillips' DRS confusion in 1st IND vs NZ Test

Published - 19 Nov 2026, 09:45 AM | Updated - 19 Nov 2026, 09:48 AM

Shubman Gill
Image Credits: X

India captain Shubman Gill was visibly frustrated after India lost a DRS review against Glenn Phillips on Day 1 of the first Test against New Zealand. Gill questioned on-field umpire Richard Illingworth after third umpire Paul Reiffel upheld the not-out decision off Jasprit Bumrah's bowling.

India had won the toss and elected to bowl at the Basin Reserve in Wellington on Thursday, November 19, putting New Zealand under pressure from the start. The hosts reached 60/4 at lunch after losing four wickets in the opening session, with India's pace attack troubling their batters throughout the morning.

Shubman Gill Questions Glenn Phillips' DRS Decision After Paul Reiffel's Verdict

Shubman Gill was unhappy after India's review against Glenn Phillips failed in the 31st over. Jasprit Bumrah bowled a delivery that moved back sharply, beat Phillips' bat and appeared to hit him in front of the stumps. India appealed for LBW, but Illingworth turned it down.

Gill discussed the decision with Bumrah and the wicketkeeper before opting for a review. Bumrah felt the delivery was too high and told his captain, "height hai" [it's high]. Gill, however, believed Phillips had not edged the ball and replied, "bat nahi hai" [no bat].

The Snickometer showed a big spike when the ball passed close to the bat. However, the front-on angle did not clearly show an inside edge. After reviewing the footage several times, third umpire Paul Reiffel asked for another slow-motion replay.

He concluded that the ball had taken a slight deflection off the bat before hitting Phillips' back pad and upheld Illingworth's not-out decision. Gill remained unconvinced and approached Illingworth, arguing that there was a clear gap between the bat and pad and that the ball had struck Phillips' pad first.

The umpire explained the decision, but the India captain walked away shaking his head. Bumrah and the other Indian players also appeared unhappy with the verdict. The delivery also appeared to be going over the stumps, meaning the LBW appeal would most likely have been unsuccessful even without an inside edge.

Jasprit Bumrah Leads India's Pace Attack to Four First-Session Wickets

India's fast bowlers dominated the opening session after Shubman Gill elected to bowl at the Basin Reserve. Jasprit Bumrah claimed two wickets, while Anshul Kamboj and Akash Deep picked up one each as New Zealand struggled to reach 60/4 by lunch.

Bumrah gave India an early breakthrough in the first over by dismissing New Zealand captain Tom Latham for a two-ball duck. The right-arm pacer bowled a good-length delivery that moved back sharply and crashed into the top of the off-stump after Latham left it.

India continued to put pressure on the hosts after the break, claiming another wicket before the DRS controversy involving Phillips in the 31st over.

Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja Miss Out as Rishabh Pant Returns

Shubman Gill opted for four specialist pacers, with Jasprit Bumrah, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna featuring in the playing XI. Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja missed out, while Washington Sundar was selected as the lone spin-bowling all-rounder.

The match also marked Rishabh Pant's return to the side after recovering from injury. Dhruv Jurel retained his place as a specialist batter alongside Pant.

India playing XI: KL Rahul, Yashasvi Jaiswal, Devdutt Padikkal, Shubman Gill (c), Rishabh Pant, Washington Sundar, Dhruv Jurel (wk), Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj, Jasprit Bumrah, Prasidh Krishna.

New Zealand playing XI: Tom Latham (c), Devon Conway, Henry Nicholls, Rachin Ravindra, Daryl Mitchell, Tom Blundell (wk), Glenn Phillips, Nathan Smith, Kyle Jamieson, Matt Henry, Jacob Duffy.

Also read: Yuzvendra Chahal becomes first Indian bowler to take 400 T20 wickets

Sai Vaitla
Sai Vaitla

Sai Vaitla is an author at Cricketaddictor and he has been working since September 2022. Sai Vaitla...

logo
Stay Updated with the Latest Cricket News from Cricket Addictor.

You will receive the latest updates on cricket news throughout the day. You can manage them whenever you need in browser settings.