Former Australian Test opener Cameron Bancroft has reignited the 2018 ball-tampering controversy with fresh allegations. In a 4,000-word column published in The West Australian on November 18, Bancroft claimed that the entire Australian team and coaching staff knew about the plan, including the bowlers.
Usman Khawaja also addressed the ball-tampering controversy in his recently released autobiography, 'Sabr'. Cricket Australia CEO Todd Greenberg has said the newly announced independent forum will provide a platform for those involved to speak but will not reopen the original investigation or impose retrospective sanctions.
3. Termination of Pat Cummins' Cricket Australia Contract
Pat Cummins could face termination of his central Cricket Australia contract if Cameron Bancroft's allegations are substantiated. National contracts require players to uphold the spirit of the game, cooperate with integrity investigations and protect the reputation of Australian cricket.
If an independent review establishes that Cummins knew about the ball-tampering plan in 2018 and subsequently misled the original investigation or the public, Cricket Australia could consider cancelling his contract.
Losing his central retainer would also affect his commercial endorsements and could leave him relying on freelance T20 opportunities unless the board reinstates him. Bancroft admitted that he had withheld information during the original investigation to protect his teammates and coaches. He wrote:
“It was not just the three of us – Steve Smith, David Warner and I – who knew about me using sandpaper on the ball in South Africa. It was the whole team. When I was questioned during Cricket Australia’s investigation, I did not give a complete and truthful account."
2. Removal as Australia's Test and ODI Captain
Pat Cummins could also lose his leadership positions if the allegations against him are proven. Cricket Australia removed Steve Smith as captain after the 2018 scandal, maintaining that the national skipper was responsible for the team's culture and conduct.
Cummins became Australia's Test captain in 2021, with his reputation for integrity and leadership playing an important role in restoring public confidence after the Cape Town incident. However, Bancroft's latest claims have raised questions about whether the fast bowler knew about the plan.
Bancroft alleged that the Australian bowlers, including Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon, regularly provided feedback on the condition of the ball and how well it was swinging. He recalled hearing the bowlers ask:
"Is it going yet? It's not going yet, it needs more,"
Bancroft also named former bowling coach David Saker, alleging that he instructed and encouraged the ball-tampering tactic and celebrated it within the group. Team media manager Kate Hutchison was reportedly the only member of the touring party to express reservations.
If these allegations are substantiated, Pat Cummins could come under pressure to step down or be removed as Australia's Test and ODI captain. Cricket Australia could take that step to protect the team's credibility ahead of major international tournaments and Test series.
1. International Cricket Ban
The most severe punishment Pat Cummins could face is a suspension from international and domestic cricket. Such a penalty would mirror the action Cricket Australia took against the three players directly punished after the 2018 scandal.
Steve Smith and David Warner received 12-month bans, while Bancroft was suspended for nine months. The remaining members of the squad escaped punishment at the time.
If Cricket Australia decides to extend accountability to other players involved in the incident, Pat Cummins could face a multi-month suspension from its sanctioned competitions. A ban would rule him out of important international fixtures and could significantly affect the remainder of his career.
Also read: Cricket Australia announces independent forum to revisit 2018 ball-tampering scandal